1854: A Hotel Burned to Ash, a Verdict Reversed: James Bentley Convicted in Melbourne Over the Death of James Scobie

James Bentley owned the Eureka Hotel on the Ballarat goldfields, and when gold miner James Scobie was beaten to death outside it one October night, a local magistrate, who happened to be Bentley's own friend and business associate, dismissed the case. Furious diggers were convinced it was murder covered up by a mate on the bench, and within days their anger boiled over: a crowd burned the Eureka Hotel to the ground, an act of unrest that fed directly into the tensions building toward the Eureka Stockade uprising weeks later.

The outcry forced the government to order a fresh trial, and Bentley, along with Melbourne co-accused Thomas Farrell and William Hance, was retried there. On this day in 1854, all three were convicted of manslaughter over Scobie's death and sentenced to three years of hard labour on a road gang. Bentley's wife Catherine, also charged, was acquitted.

Site of Bentley's Hotel, Eureka | National Library of Australia
National Library of Australia

⬅ See all events from 18 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1862: He Lied About Her, Then Confessed on the Scaffold: Hanged in Hobart for an Armed Robbery

William Mulligan broke into an isolated farm hut outside Hobart on 3 September 1862, minutes after Johanna Harbach's husband had left to tend the horses of a passing mail coach. He held a pistol on her, threatened to shoot her, dragged her back inside when she tried to flee, and robbed the house of its money.

At his trial he refused to cross-examine a single witness, reserving his defence for later, and in the weeks that followed he let it be known that Harbach's character was not what it seemed. He was convicted and hanged in Hobart on this day in 1862, attended on the scaffold by a vicar general who had sat with him since his condemnation.

Moments before his death Mulligan, handed over a written statement retracting everything he had said against her: "Whatever I have said injurious to the character of the woman I assaulted is entirely false, as far as I know, not a word can be said against her".

1860s site of execution photograph of Hobart town and Campbell Street Gaol
1860s site of execution photograph of Hobart town and Campbell Street Gaol

⬅ See all events from 18 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1879: Recruited From a Melbourne Brothel: Gus Wernicke, Australia's Youngest Bushranger, Shot Dead in a Farmhouse Siege

Gus Wernicke was recruited into the bushranging gang of Captain Moonlite (Andrew George Scott) straight out of a brothel in Melbourne, where Scott later said he found him 'suffering from disease and covered with vermin'. A runaway apprentice plumber who had been flogged and docked pay over a lost coin, the teenager drifted into Moonlite's orbit and, by most accounts, became Australia's youngest bushranger.

On this day in 1879, the gang was cornered by police troopers at a selector's farmhouse near Gundagai in southern New South Wales. Wernicke slipped outside hoping to outflank the troopers but was shot and clubbed with a rifle butt; he was carried back inside and died in Scott's arms in the farmhouse kitchen, calling out for his captain.

When word reached Melbourne that his son was dead, Wernicke's father, a publican, gave reporters a single chilling line: 'I am very glad he is shot.'

Gus Wernicke: Bushranger
Gus Wernicke: Bushranger

⬅ See all events from 18 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1881: "That's the Man That Stabbed Me": the Dying Trooper Who Named His Killer

Robert Johnson, who travelled under the alias William Nugent, had three horses and an outstanding warrant for supplying liquor to Aboriginal people near Wellington when Trooper Harry Pearce caught up with him on the road to Kingston, South Australia, that May. The two rode off together on apparently friendly terms, but when Johnson dismounted to light his pipe and refused to go further, Pearce moved to handcuff him, and Johnson drew a knife, stabbing him again and again before unsaddling his horse and riding away.

Pearce lay in the roadside grass for hours before a passerby found him waving a handkerchief. Carried into Kingston, he lived four more days, long enough to identify his attacker from his sickbed: "That's the man that stabbed me, and that's the knife he did it with." Johnson was run down soon after, his knife still stained with blood, and at his trial that October a jury needed only fifteen minutes to convict him of wilful murder.

He petitioned the governor for mercy, arguing the trooper had provoked him by trying to handcuff him over the unlit pipe, but the plea was refused, and he was hanged at Mount Gambier on this day in 1881.

On the scaffold he made no statement beyond a final request to his priest: "See that my body is put in consecrated ground." The law required otherwise, and he was buried within the gaol walls.

Buried within the walls of Mount Gambier Gaol: State Library of South Australia
Buried within the walls of Mount Gambier Gaol: State Library of South Australia

⬅ See all events from 18 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.