1854: A Hotel Burned to Ash, a Verdict Reversed: James Bentley Convicted in Melbourne Over the Death of James Scobie
James Bentley owned the Eureka Hotel on the Ballarat goldfields, and when gold miner James Scobie was beaten to death outside it one October night, a local magistrate, who happened to be Bentley's own friend and business associate, dismissed the case. Furious diggers were convinced it was murder covered up by a mate on the bench, and within days their anger boiled over: a crowd burned the Eureka Hotel to the ground, an act of unrest that fed directly into the tensions building toward the Eureka Stockade uprising weeks later.
The outcry forced the government to order a fresh trial, and Bentley, along with Melbourne co-accused Thomas Farrell and William Hance, was retried there. On this day in 1854, all three were convicted of manslaughter over Scobie's death and sentenced to three years of hard labour on a road gang. Bentley's wife Catherine, also charged, was acquitted.

