1804: He Chose a Stranger for His Last Goodbye: Hanged in Sydney for Assault

John Green, who said he had been born in Pennsylvania, committed an assault in the bush near Parramatta, then fled armed with an axe. Settlers, soldiers and the colony's newly formed police association scoured the countryside for days until a soldier levelled a pistol at him and forced his surrender.

Tried and convicted in Sydney, Green was hanged on this day in 1804. Standing on the scaffold, he picked a young man out of the watching crowd, called him forward by name, and asked to embrace him one last time before the trapdoor fell.

He had denied the charge outright in court, but on the morning of his execution he wept, expressed deep remorse, and admitted he had earlier been convicted in Great Britain and transported to the colony aboard the Coromandel.

Sydney 1804 - Year of the Execution | National Library of Australia
National Library of Australia

⬅ See all events from 21 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1879: Recruited From a Melbourne Brothel: Gus Wernicke, Australia's Youngest Bushranger, Shot Dead in a Farmhouse Siege

Gus Wernicke was recruited into the bushranging gang of Captain Moonlite (Andrew George Scott) straight out of a brothel in Melbourne, where Scott later said he found him 'suffering from disease and covered with vermin'. A runaway apprentice plumber who had been flogged and docked pay over a lost coin, the teenager drifted into Moonlite's orbit and, by most accounts, became Australia's youngest bushranger.

On this day in 1879, the gang was cornered by police troopers at a selector's farmhouse near Gundagai in southern New South Wales. Wernicke slipped outside hoping to outflank the troopers but was shot and clubbed with a rifle butt; he was carried back inside and died in Scott's arms in the farmhouse kitchen, calling out for his captain.

When word reached Melbourne that his son was dead, Wernicke's father, a publican, gave reporters a single chilling line: 'I am very glad he is shot.'

Gus Wernicke: Bushranger
Gus Wernicke: Bushranger

⬅ See all events from 18 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1795: Pardoned on the Gallows: One Housebreaker Hanged in Sydney, His Accomplice Spared

William Smith and an accomplice named Whitehouse broke into a house outside Sydney, tearing the place apart, killing the livestock and beating a servant before making off with a bundle of clothing and brooches worth around 32 shillings.

Both men were convicted and sentenced to hang together. On 16 November 1795 they were led out to the gallows side by side, the rope prepared for each of them, when the Governor stepped in at the last moment and pardoned Whitehouse. Smith was left to die alone.

A direct north general view of Sydney Cove... 1794... / oil painting | Dixson Galleries:State Library of NSW
Dixson Galleries:State Library of NSW

⬅ See all events from 16 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1816: He Hid the Stolen Goods in His Own Well: a Blacksmith Hanged in Sydney for Burglary

James Flavell was a blacksmith with a once-thriving trade in Castlereagh Street, next door to a hairdresser named Thomas Reeds. One night that June, Flavell, his servant William Tripp and his apprentice broke through the brick wall between the two houses, stripped Reeds of his clothing and valuables, and hid part of the loot, along with their housebreaking tools, down Flavell's own well. The rest was buried near Farm Cove, and Flavell took his apprentice to a neighbour's house afterwards to build himself an alibi.

The scheme unravelled when an accomplice turned Crown witness, and when the apprentice later found a silk handkerchief floating in the well and was told by his master to lie about where he had found it. Flavell and Tripp were convicted of burglary and hanged in Sydney on 15 November 1816, alongside a third man executed for cattle theft.

According to the newspaper report, the condemned men conducted themselves in their final moments in a becoming manner and died penitently.

The Blacksmith's Forge: by Johann Hamza
The Blacksmith's Forge: by Johann Hamza

⬅ See all events from 15 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.