1834: Risking the Gallows to Avoid a Flogging: Two Hanged in Sydney for the Murder of Dr Wardell

Dr Robert Wardell, a Sydney barrister and co-founder of The Australian newspaper, was inspecting his Petersham estate one Sunday afternoon when he rode straight into the bark hut of three runaway convicts, among them a teenage absconder named Brace. Trying to talk his way clear, Wardell urged the men to surrender and come quietly with him, warning it would go better for them. Brace begged his companions not to risk their lives over a matter that might cost them only fifty lashes, but John Jenkins raised his stolen gun and fired, killing Wardell on the spot.

Brace turned Crown evidence, and his account convicted both Jenkins and his companion Thomas Tattersdale, who had joined the pair partway through their bushranging spree. A jury took only minutes to find them guilty, and on this day in 1834 the two men were hanged in Sydney for the murder.

On the scaffold, Jenkins confessed to a separate killing, claiming he had once stabbed a man on the Liverpool road whose body had, he said, been devoured by the native dogs and never found. Tattersdale made no such confession, saying only that he hoped to make his peace with God.

Jenkins shooting at Dr Wardell
Jenkins shooting at Dr Wardell

⬅ See all events from 10 November

1848: Denying the Fatal Blow: John Jordan Hanged at Launceston for a Plotted Robbery Murder

John Jordan, a young shoemaker, and farmhand Patrick McDonough spent months plotting to rob an elderly settler named Zimram Youram, using a pair of boots Jordan was making for him as their pretext to keep calling at his isolated hut near Launceston. When an attempt to drug the old man failed, McDonough bludgeoned him with a wrench hammer while Jordan looked on, and the pair ransacked the hut for his hidden savings, walking away with about 17 pounds in coins and notes.

The two men quickly turned on each other. Jordan's confession named McDonough as the killer, while McDonough claimed Jordan had struck the blow. A powerful defence swayed the jury and McDonough walked free of the murder charge, though he was held for the robbery; Jordan was convicted and condemned. He was hanged at Launceston on this day in 1848.

On the scaffold, Jordan insisted he had not struck the fatal blow and had tried to stop the killing, declaring that it would one day be discovered who truly committed it. His last words, delivered calmly to the crowd, were "God bless you all."

Was Lady Justice Correct?
Was Lady Justice Correct?

⬅ See all events from 7 November

1848: Black-Faced and Armed: Matthew Mahide Hanged at Launceston for Robbery

Matthew Mahide held up the property of George Stancombe with his face blackened and a weapon in hand, the kind of disguised, armed bushranging that terrorised rural Tasmanian households in the 1840s. Convicted of the offence, he was sentenced to death.

He was hanged at Launceston on 7 November 1848. On the scaffold he said nothing at all, appearing, in the words of a witness, more dead than alive as the hangman did his work. Rather than being sent for dissection, his body was carried to the Crown Inn for a wake kept after the custom of his country, before burial in the Catholic burial ground.

Convicts plundering settlers homesteads illustration
Convicts plundering settlers homesteads illustration

⬅ See all events from 7 November

2000: The Diamond Heist That Was Really a Trap: Police Foil a 350-Million-Pound Raid on the Millennium Dome

A seven-man gang planned to smash into the Millennium Dome's diamond exhibition, grab a haul worth 350 million pounds, and roar off down the Thames on a speedboat. It was a bold escape plan for a bold crime, but the gang never got the chance to use it.

Police had been watching for weeks. Surveillance cameras had already filmed members of the crew casing and videoing the exhibition beforehand, and on this day in 2000, a 100-strong police operation was waiting the moment they struck, ready to close in before the gang could reach the river.

Had they somehow broken through and made it to their boat, there was one final twist waiting for them: the diamonds on display that day were fakes, the real stones having already been quietly removed for safekeeping.

02 Arena in London. London, UK - January 21, 2014: The O2 Arena in London at sunset. The venue contains shops, bars, cinemas, clubs and often holds entertainment concerts. | ID 36920457 © Mike Clegg | Dreamstime.com
ID 36920457 © Mike Clegg | Dreamstime.com

⬅ See all events from 7 November

On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.