1859: Confessing to Murder, Denying the Brutality: A Young Man Hanged in Melbourne

William Siddons, a young labourer newly arrived from London with no family in the colony, faced trial at a Ballarat circuit court and was convicted of a capital offence.

He was hanged in Melbourne on this day in 1859. Witnesses described him facing the gallows with composure, and just before the drop he asked that reporters be brought to him so he could make one final statement.

Siddons confessed to the capital offence itself, but to the last denied the additional brutality the evidence had suggested, repeating that denial to the journalists gathered around him before he died without a struggle.

Ballarat Circuit Court: 1859 Australia
Ballarat Circuit Court: 1859 Australia

⬅ See all events from 17 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1911: Spurned by the Family He Hoped To Marry Into, a Mackay Farmhand Takes Revenge

George Silva worked as a farmhand for the Ching family at Alligator Creek, south of Mackay, and wanted to marry the eldest daughter, Maud. He told a neighbour he would soon have land and a house of his own, only to be told: "You got no money. You got no blanket. No decent trousers." Maud and her family turned him down flat.

On 17 November 1911, with her husband away in town, Silva shot and bludgeoned to death Agnes Ching and five of her children inside their home. Two of the youngest were found days later in a nearby paddock, killed the same way.

Under questioning, Silva first blamed a Hindu neighbour and a local farmhand for helping him, but police found no evidence of any accomplices and both men were cleared. Tried only over Maud's death, he admitted being present but denied striking the fatal blows; the jury convicted him in twenty minutes. He was hanged in Brisbane on 10 June 1912.

On the scaffold, Silva tried to delay his own death by reciting scripture, and was still speaking mid-sentence when the trapdoor fell.

George Silva 1911
George Silva 1911

⬅ See all events from 17 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1795: Pardoned on the Gallows: One Housebreaker Hanged in Sydney, His Accomplice Spared

William Smith and an accomplice named Whitehouse broke into a house outside Sydney, tearing the place apart, killing the livestock and beating a servant before making off with a bundle of clothing and brooches worth around 32 shillings.

Both men were convicted and sentenced to hang together. On 16 November 1795 they were led out to the gallows side by side, the rope prepared for each of them, when the Governor stepped in at the last moment and pardoned Whitehouse. Smith was left to die alone.

A direct north general view of Sydney Cove... 1794... / oil painting | Dixson Galleries:State Library of NSW
Dixson Galleries:State Library of NSW

⬅ See all events from 16 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1906: A Bolting Horse Led Police to a Murder: Hanged in Adelaide.

Notella Habibulla thought a bolting horse was just bad luck. Instead it hanged him. On the night of 12 August 1906 a blood-soaked pony and buggy careered driverless through Adelaide and crashed outside his mother-in-law's house, with a mat and a shirt in the tray soaked in blood. Habibulla told police the horse had simply bolted from the bridge; detectives thought otherwise.

A search of his Bristol Street home turned up a pool of blood in the yard, drag marks to the gate, and his wife Edith's torn clothing hidden beneath the bed. When police dragged the nearby river, they pulled up two severed legs in a sugar sack, and days later the rest of her dismembered body.

A jury convicted Habibulla of her murder, though they added a recommendation for mercy. It made no difference: he was hanged in Adelaide on this day in 1906, two visiting priests reciting prayers of his own faith as he walked to the scaffold.

Facing death, Habibulla told the gaol governor he was unafraid: "A man can only die once; but I should like to have lived."

A Bolting Horse Led Police to a Murder: Hanged in <a href='https://darkstories.com.au/adelaide-true-crime-tour/' target='_blank' rel='noopener noreferrer'>Adelaide</a>.

⬅ See all events from 16 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.