Dark Stories: On This Day In True Crime History - Dark Stories True Crime Tours

1776: But One Life to Give: Nathan Hale Hanged as a Spy in New York City

Captain Nathan Hale, a young American officer serving under George Washington, was captured behind British lines on Long Island while gathering intelligence on troop movements ahead of the British occupation of New York City. Found with incriminating documents hidden in his boots, he was condemned without a formal trial and hanged by the British the following morning, on the orders of General William Howe.

Hale was reportedly denied the services of a clergyman and even a Bible in his final hours. He was hanged from a tree or ladder, with no gallows or drop, meaning death likely came slowly by strangulation rather than a broken neck.

His last words are reputed to have been, “I only regret that I have but one life to give for my country,” a line said to echo a sentiment from a play he had read, and one that transformed him into an enduring symbol of American revolutionary sacrifice despite his execution as a spy.

Nathan Hale statue detail with partial quote I have but one

⬅ See all events from 22 September

Espionage Execution New York City Political Crime USA War Crime

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1933: The Michigan City Breakout: Ten Men Escape Using Guns Smuggled by John Dillinger

On September 22, 1933, ten prisoners broke out of the Indiana State Prison at Michigan City in a violent escape that killed two guards. The breakout was planned from inside by seasoned bank robber Harry Pierpont, with handguns smuggled to the crew by John Dillinger, freshly paroled after nine years behind bars, using arrangements made by Pierpont’s girlfriend.

In a strange twist, Dillinger himself was not among the men who walked free that day. Just days earlier he had been arrested and jailed in Dayton, Ohio, meaning his former cellmates had to turn around and break him out shortly after springing themselves. The escapees would go on to form the core of the notorious Dillinger gang, launching a violent crime spree across the American Midwest.

A Government agent later wrote that Dillinger’s career “graphically illustrates the inadequacies of our system,” noting that nine years in prison had done nothing to rehabilitate a man determined to become a professional bank robber.

⬅ See all events from 22 September

Escape Gang Indiana Ohio Organised Crime Prison Robbery USA

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1913: The Last Man Hanged in Queensland Walks to the Brisbane Gallows

Ernest Austin was the last person ever executed in Queensland. The 23-year-old farm labourer was hanged in Brisbane in September 1913 for a murder committed at Samford three months earlier. Reporters noted that the brilliance of the spring morning made it hard to grasp what was happening a few yards away. A chaplain led the procession to the scaffold, reciting the burial service. The condemned man looked in remarkably good health; his appetite had stayed “voracious to the very last”, and he had gained 28 pounds in gaol. Asked if he had anything to say, he spoke in low, clear tones, waving his right hand for emphasis: “I say straight out that I quite deserve this punishment.” As the white cap was drawn over his face he added: “Send a wire to my mother.”

Prison identification photo of Ernest Austin last man hanged in Queensland

⬅ See all events from 22 September

Australia Brisbane Execution Murder QLD Trial

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1656: Never Pregnant, Never Guilty: Colonial America’s First All-Female Jury Acquits an Accused Child-Killer

In September 1656 the General Provincial Court at Patuxent, Maryland impanelled the first all-woman jury in the American colonies to try Judith Catchpole, an indentured maidservant accused of murdering her newborn child. The accusation came from a fellow passenger on the voyage from England, who also claimed she had cut a sleeping woman’s throat and stabbed a seaman in the back, then, in the same breath, that she had stitched the throat wound closed before the victim woke and rubbed grease on the seaman’s wound to bring him back to life.

The jury of seven married and four single women was chosen specifically because the case turned on medical evidence only women could assess: whether Catchpole’s body showed any sign of having recently given birth. Their physical examination found no such evidence, and witnesses testified that her accuser, who had died before the trial, was not of sound mind.

Catchpole’s defence rested on a simple claim: she had never been pregnant at all. With no proof of childbirth and the accuser’s own tales dismissed as delusional talk of witchcraft, the jury acquitted her of every charge.

⬅ See all events from 22 September

Acquittal Infanticide Maryland Trial USA Witchcraft Womens History

1776: But One Life to Give: Nathan Hale Hanged as a Spy in New York City

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1933: The Michigan City Breakout: Ten Men Escape Using Guns Smuggled by John Dillinger

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1913: The Last Man Hanged in Queensland Walks to the Brisbane Gallows

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1656: Never Pregnant, Never Guilty: Colonial America’s First All-Female Jury Acquits an Accused Child-Killer

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

Subscribe to Dark Stories