1966: Acquitted at Retrial: The Murder Case Hollywood Insisted Had Nothing to Do With The Fugitive

Sam Sheppard had already served ten years in prison for the 1954 bludgeoning murder of his pregnant wife, Marilyn, when his conviction was thrown out over what reviewers called a circus-like trial. At his 1966 retrial, defence lawyer F. Lee Bailey tore into the prosecution witnesses, dismissing their case as "ten pounds of hogwash in a five-pound bag." On this day in 1966, after a sequestered jury deliberated for 12 hours, Sheppard walked free.

The case outlived the verdict. The television series The Fugitive, and the 1993 film that followed it, were long rumoured to be drawn from Sheppard's ordeal: a doctor wrongly convicted of killing his wife, hunting the real intruder himself. Its creator always and firmly denied any connection to the case.

Yet the denial has never mattered. Whatever the truth of the resemblance, Sheppard's story and The Fugitive remain fused in the public mind, one of those rare cases where the culture has simply decided the link is real, and no amount of official disavowal has ever managed to pull them apart.

The Fugitive TV and Film Show: Related or Not to this Case
The Fugitive TV and Film Show: Related or Not to this Case

⬅ See all events from 16 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1995: "If It Doesn’t Fit, You Must Acquit": O.J. Simpson Walks Free

O.J. Simpson, the former football star, stood accused of murdering his ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend Ronald Goldman outside her Los Angeles home in June 1994. The trial became a media spectacle, dominating television and public debate across the United States and beyond. The defense seized on a single moment: prosecutors had Simpson try on the bloody glove found at the scene, and it appeared too tight to fit. Defense attorney Johnnie Cochran turned the moment into a rallying cry, "If it doesn't fit, you must acquit," and on October 3, 1995, the jury returned a not guilty verdict after less than four hours of deliberation.

If It Doesn't Fit, You Must Acquite
If It Doesn't Fit, You Must Acquite

⬅ See all events from 3 October

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1656: Never Pregnant, Never Guilty: Colonial America's First All-Female Jury Acquits an Accused Child-Killer

In September 1656 the General Provincial Court at Patuxent, Maryland impanelled the first all-woman jury in the American colonies to try Judith Catchpole, an indentured maidservant accused of murdering her newborn child. The accusation came from a fellow passenger on the voyage from England, who also claimed she had cut a sleeping woman's throat and stabbed a seaman in the back, then, in the same breath, that she had stitched the throat wound closed before the victim woke and rubbed grease on the seaman's wound to bring him back to life.

The jury of seven married and four single women was chosen specifically because the case turned on medical evidence only women could assess: whether Catchpole's body showed any sign of having recently given birth. Their physical examination found no such evidence, and witnesses testified that her accuser, who had died before the trial, was not of sound mind.

Catchpole's defence rested on a simple claim: she had never been pregnant at all. With no proof of childbirth and the accuser's own tales dismissed as delusional talk of witchcraft, the jury acquitted her of every charge.

Maidservant 17th Century.
Maidservant 17th Century.

⬅ See all events from 22 September

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.