2008: The Hidden Toll of the Melbourne Gangland War: Mother of Carl Williams Found Dead at Home

Barbara Williams had already watched the Melbourne gangland war consume her family. Her son Carl Williams, one of the conflict's most notorious killers, was serving a lengthy prison sentence for murder when she was found dead at her home on this day in 2008.

She had been suffering from depression in the years since his imprisonment, and had died from a drug overdose, taking her own life.

Gangland: more than a dictionary definition in Melbourne, 1998–2010.
Gangland: more than a dictionary definition in Melbourne, 1998–2010.

⬅ See all events from 22 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1859: "Did I not get out of it well?": The Boast That Hanged a Miner in Melbourne

Henry Brown, who had escaped slavery in the United States, worked as a miner on the Victorian goldfields near Wedderburn, where he and George Tickner were mates until an affair with Tickner's wife, which produced a child, drove them apart. The two reconciled and went back to mining together, and on 25 March 1859 Brown raised the alarm that Tickner had been buried alive in a collapsed drive.

The scene did not add up. Pick marks scored the roof of the drive as though earth had been deliberately brought down on Tickner after a blow above the eye had stunned him, and a witness recalled seeing Brown peer into the hole, then glance around to check if he was being watched, before he called for help. At the inquest, when a juror told him he could not pity a man who would do "so black a deed", Brown simply nodded at the open verdict and asked, "did I not get out of it well?" Convicted of wilful murder, he was hanged in Melbourne on 21 November 1859.

On the eve of his execution he confessed to his ministers that he had dashed a stone at Tickner's head during a renewed quarrel over the affair, then buried the body in panic, insisting to the end that the killing had been without malice.

Did not get out of it so well.
Did not get out of it so well.

⬅ See all events from 21 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1898: A False Name Could Not Save Him: Alfred Archer Hanged in Melbourne for Murdering His Camp Mate

Alfred Archer and his mate William Matthews had camped together for weeks near the Victorian town of Strathmerton when Matthews vanished that September; his body turned up sewn into sacks in a creek, his skull fractured and his throat cut. Archer fled to Melbourne and gave a false name, but a landlady who had put him up days earlier recognised him on sight. Confronted, he flung off his coat and blurted out, "I am Fred Archer. I admit selling the horse and cart, but I deny the rest."

At trial, a pickaxe was found to match the fracture in Matthews's skull and a knife from the camp fitted the wounds to his throat. Archer was convicted and hanged in Melbourne on 21 November 1898.

Though he had pleaded not guilty throughout, Archer had secretly confessed to the murder before his trial even began, a fact kept hidden until after his death; he admitted waiting until Matthews fell asleep before striking him with the pickaxe for the few pounds he carried, then cutting his throat to be certain. On the scaffold he thanked his gaolers, saying he was "prepared to meet my God."

Murdered his Mate: VPRS 515/P0000, PROV.
Murdered his Mate: VPRS 515/P0000, PROV.

⬅ See all events from 21 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1854: A Hotel Burned to Ash, a Verdict Reversed: James Bentley Convicted in Melbourne Over the Death of James Scobie

James Bentley owned the Eureka Hotel on the Ballarat goldfields, and when gold miner James Scobie was beaten to death outside it one October night, a local magistrate, who happened to be Bentley's own friend and business associate, dismissed the case. Furious diggers were convinced it was murder covered up by a mate on the bench, and within days their anger boiled over: a crowd burned the Eureka Hotel to the ground, an act of unrest that fed directly into the tensions building toward the Eureka Stockade uprising weeks later.

The outcry forced the government to order a fresh trial, and Bentley, along with Melbourne co-accused Thomas Farrell and William Hance, was retried there. On this day in 1854, all three were convicted of manslaughter over Scobie's death and sentenced to three years of hard labour on a road gang. Bentley's wife Catherine, also charged, was acquitted.

Site of Bentley's Hotel, Eureka | National Library of Australia
National Library of Australia

⬅ See all events from 18 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.