1898: A False Name Could Not Save Him: Alfred Archer Hanged in Melbourne for Murdering His Camp Mate

Alfred Archer and his mate William Matthews had camped together for weeks near the Victorian town of Strathmerton when Matthews vanished that September; his body turned up sewn into sacks in a creek, his skull fractured and his throat cut. Archer fled to Melbourne and gave a false name, but a landlady who had put him up days earlier recognised him on sight. Confronted, he flung off his coat and blurted out, "I am Fred Archer. I admit selling the horse and cart, but I deny the rest."

At trial, a pickaxe was found to match the fracture in Matthews's skull and a knife from the camp fitted the wounds to his throat. Archer was convicted and hanged in Melbourne on 21 November 1898.

Though he had pleaded not guilty throughout, Archer had secretly confessed to the murder before his trial even began, a fact kept hidden until after his death; he admitted waiting until Matthews fell asleep before striking him with the pickaxe for the few pounds he carried, then cutting his throat to be certain. On the scaffold he thanked his gaolers, saying he was "prepared to meet my God."

Murdered his Mate: VPRS 515/P0000, PROV.
Murdered his Mate: VPRS 515/P0000, PROV.

⬅ See all events from 21 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1848: Denying the Fatal Blow: John Jordan Hanged at Launceston for a Plotted Robbery Murder

John Jordan, a young shoemaker, and farmhand Patrick McDonough spent months plotting to rob an elderly settler named Zimram Youram, using a pair of boots Jordan was making for him as their pretext to keep calling at his isolated hut near Launceston. When an attempt to drug the old man failed, McDonough bludgeoned him with a wrench hammer while Jordan looked on, and the pair ransacked the hut for his hidden savings, walking away with about 17 pounds in coins and notes.

The two men quickly turned on each other. Jordan's confession named McDonough as the killer, while McDonough claimed Jordan had struck the blow. A powerful defence swayed the jury and McDonough walked free of the murder charge, though he was held for the robbery; Jordan was convicted and condemned. He was hanged at Launceston on this day in 1848.

On the scaffold, Jordan insisted he had not struck the fatal blow and had tried to stop the killing, declaring that it would one day be discovered who truly committed it. His last words, delivered calmly to the crowd, were "God bless you all."

Was Lady Justice Correct?
Was Lady Justice Correct?

⬅ See all events from 7 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1895: "A Feeling of Relief": Hanged in Melbourne for Drowning a Family Member

Emma Williams, a young widow living in South Melbourne, told the man she was living with that her toddler son John had become "a nuisance". One Sunday evening in August 1895, she carried him down the Port Melbourne pier, tied a stone weighing nearly 15 pounds to his frock with braid torn from her own dress, and dropped him into the lagoon.

She told her housemates she had given the boy to a Salvation Army woman, but when her lover read a newspaper report of a child's body pulled from the water and confronted her, she broke. "I have only to say: I done it," she told detectives. She described waiting half an hour by the water to see whether her son would surface, admitting she felt nothing but relief when he did not.

Williams made a full confession to police, declaring, "I will tell you everything from first to last." A jury convicted her of murder within twenty minutes, and she was hanged in Melbourne on 4 November 1895.

Emma Williams: Public Record Office Victoria, Central Register of Female Prisoners, VPRS 516/P0000, 5926–6415 (1891–1896)
Emma Williams: Public Record Office Victoria, Central Register of Female Prisoners, VPRS 516/P0000, 5926–6415 (1891–1896)

⬅ See all events from 4 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1875: The Dream That Led to a Body: William Page Hanged at Mount Gambier for the Murder of Mary Buchan

William Page, a groom at Hedley Park near Mount Gambier, had courted a young woman named Mary Buchan for months, though she confessed to her family that she loved him but feared him. On the night of 11 July 1875 she left to walk with him after church and was never seen alive again.

Weeks of fruitless searching followed, until two people who had never met, Buchan's own father and the wife of the investigating police inspector, each separately dreamed that the dead girl led them to a ploughed field marked by three trees. Acting on the strange coincidence, police searched the spot and found her body buried about eighteen inches down, her hands bound with her own handkerchief.

Page was arrested, tried, and hanged at Mount Gambier on this day in 1875.

In a signed confession he admitted striking Buchan with a stockwhip handle after she tried to end their relationship, then strangling her when he believed the blow had been fatal. He insisted the killing was done only 'in a fit of passion' and expressed deep remorse before his death.

A Dream led them to the same location.
A Dream led them to the same location.

⬅ See all events from 27 October

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.