1721: The Housebreaker Who Could Not Stay Away: Hanged at Tyburn for Returning from Transportation

John Meff was a housebreaker who had already cheated the gallows once, having been convicted and then transported to the colonies rather than executed. But transportation was meant to be permanent exile, and Meff broke its terms by making his way back to England, a crime that under the law of the day carried the same penalty as the original offence: death.

He was arrested, tried, and sentenced to hang for illegally returning from transportation. On 11 September 1721 he was taken to Tyburn and executed at the age of forty, going to the gallows alongside James Redding, who had been condemned separately for robbery.

For Meff the return to Tyburn marked the end of a second chance he could not keep: having once escaped the noose through transportation, the simple act of coming home proved fatal.

Life of John Meff_featured
Life of John Meff_featured

⬅ See all events from 11 September

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1786: Britain Decides to Dump Its Criminal Class on the Far Side of the World

In 1786, Britain faced a crisis of its own making. Decades of the so-called bloody code had swollen the criminal class with petty offenders, American independence had slammed shut the old dumping ground of the colonial plantations, and the gaols were bursting. The solution settled upon was audacious: ship Britain's unwanted more than 15,000 miles to New South Wales, a coastline only recently mapped by Captain Cook, who had praised the land around Botany Bay.

Over the next 80 years, more than 160,000 men and women were transported to Australia and Van Diemen's Land. Transportation meant total erasure: the loss of home, family, and identity, followed by a brutal sea crossing and survival in an utterly foreign land. Yet for many, the far side of the world offered something the old country never would: a second chance.

First Fleet ships entering Sydney Harbour 1788 illustration
First Fleet ships entering Sydney Harbour 1788 illustration

⬅ See all events from 18 August

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

John Meff: The Housebreaker Who Could Not Stay Away

John Meff is the son of French Protestant refugees who fled Louis XIV's persecution and rebuilt their lives in London. Raised with care and apprenticed to a weaver, he marries young; but when honest labour cannot feed his family, he turns to housebreaking.

Almost immediately he is caught, tried and loaded into the cart bound for the gallows: a story that should end right there. Instead, a bizarre twist of fate sends his life spiralling through pirate encounters, a desert island and a desperate return to old England, where the machinery of justice has a long memory.

This is one of the strangest true crime stories you will hear: listen now and follow Meff from the weaver's loom to the edge of the world and back again.

John Meff: The Housebreaker Who Could Not Stay Away

Follow the podcast so you never miss an episode:

Apple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusicMore apps

FROM THE 1735 TEXT

the hangman being arrested as he was going to Tyburn, he and the rest were transported through the clemency of the Government

CASE FILE No. 9
NAMEJohn Meff, alias Merth
AGEabout 40
WHEN1721
WHERELondon, Newgate, Tyburn
CHARGEHousebreaking and returning from transportation without lawful cause
FATEHanged at Tyburn, 11 September 1721
SOURCELives of the Most Remarkable Criminals, 1735
HANGED

Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.

The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode.

Marooned: today it conjures a castaway on a tropical beach, almost romantic. In old England and on the high seas it was a death sentence by abandonment: pirates would dump unwanted men on uninhabited islands with nothing, leaving the sun and starvation to do the killing.

Springes: simple snare traps made from whatever flexible material was at hand: cord, wire, or in Meff's desperate case, strands pulled from an old horsehair wig. A springe would tighten around a bird's leg when triggered; on a barren island it could mean the difference between eating and dying.

Fluxes: a word for severe, often bloody diarrhoea, the kind that killed as readily as any fever in the eighteenth century. When the text says the island animals threw the castaways into 'dangerous fluxes,' it means men too weak to stand, wasting away from food their bodies could not tolerate.

Plantations: not merely farms. In old England this word meant the colonies, especially in the Caribbean and the Americas, where transported convicts were sent to serve out their sentences as forced labourers. It was exile dressed up as mercy.

Act of Indemnity: a sweeping legal pardon issued by the government, sometimes covering whole categories of offence. Meff hoped it would wipe his slate clean; the court had other ideas, since his real crime was returning from transportation itself.

Returning from transportation: in old England, coming back to the country after being transported was a capital offence, no matter how you had lived abroad. The law saw it not as mere rule-breaking but as a defiance of royal mercy: you were spared the rope once, and by returning you were practically tying the noose yourself.

Impeached: today it means to charge a politician with misconduct. In old England it meant to inform on your criminal associates in exchange for your own life: a desperate bargain that could buy you another few years, if your former friends did not find you first.

Put in the cart: the condemned were loaded into an open cart at Newgate and driven through the streets to Tyburn for hanging. The phrase sounds almost casual, but the journey was a public spectacle: crowds lined the route, and taverns along the way offered the doomed a final drink.

About This Series

Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines.

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

Robert Perkins: The Baker Who Could Not Escape His Past

Robert Perkins grows up the son of a prosperous innkeeper near Hempsted in Hertfordshire, but when his mother dies and his father remarries, the boy is cast out of his own home and stripped of everything. Disinherited, apprenticed to a baker, and left to the wide world, he drifts toward drink, gambling, and the company of young men heading nowhere good.

One night in a Whitechapel alehouse, a marked crown piece is found in his pocket, and just like that, old England's justice takes hold of him and does not let go. His story is a true crime case built on small misfortunes that stack into something terrible.

Listen now to how a stolen coin set a young man on a course that would carry him across oceans and back again, with the law waiting at every shore.

Robert Perkins: The Baker Who Could Not Escape His Past

Follow the podcast so you never miss an episode:

Apple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusicMore apps

FROM THE 1735 TEXT

the ready way to force a naked uninstructed youth on the most sinful courses

CASE FILE No. 4
NAMERobert Perkins
AGEnot recorded
WHEN1721
WHEREHempsted, Hertfordshire; Whitechapel; Jamaica; Carolina; Gravesend; Tyburn
CHARGETheft and returning from transportation
FATEHanged at Tyburn, 5 July 1721
SOURCELives of the Most Remarkable Criminals, 1735
HANGED

Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.

The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode.

Mother-in-law: today this means your spouse's mother, but in old England it commonly referred to a stepmother. When the text says Perkins's 'mother-in-law' turned him out, it means the woman his father married after his real mother died.

Cast: not thrown, but convicted. In old England's courtrooms, to be 'cast' was to be found guilty; the word carried a finality that felt like being tossed aside by the law itself.

Transportation: the practice of shipping convicted criminals to colonies overseas as forced labourers. In old England it served as a middle punishment between whipping and the gallows; for someone like Perkins, it meant being sold to a planter for years of backbreaking work.

Crown piece: a silver coin worth five shillings. A marked crown was one with distinctive scratches or notches that let its owner identify it; shopkeepers in old England used this trick to catch thieves, essentially turning their own money into evidence.

Upon the rake: to go 'upon the rake' meant to go out looking for wild, dissolute fun: drinking, gambling, chasing trouble. Think of it as the old England version of a night out that everyone knows will end badly.

Shuffle-board: not the cruise-ship pastime you might picture, but a tavern game in old England where coins or discs were slid along a table. It was a common haunt of idlers and gamblers, and the text lists it alongside skittle-playing as evidence of Perkins's wasted days.

Sessions: the regular sittings of a criminal court in old England. Cases moved fast once the sessions came on; there was no long wait for trial, and for someone like Perkins, that speed was devastating.

Returning from transportation: coming back to England before your sentence of banishment had expired was a capital offence in old England. It did not matter how you had suffered abroad or how honestly you had lived since; the return itself was enough to hang you.

About This Series

Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines.

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.