1858: The Rope Broke, So They Hanged Him Again: Samuel Gibbs Executed in Melbourne for the Murder of His Wife

Samuel Gibbs, a miner working the Upper Wet Lead near Ararat, was accused of throwing his wife Anne down a disused 60 foot mine shaft after a drunken quarrel one stormy night in January 1858. She lay in the freezing hole for more than a day, her cries loud enough that at least one neighbour heard her, before she was pulled out barely alive. When first asked if her husband had done it, she insisted he had not. Only later, dying in her tent, did she change her account and say he had put her there.

Convicted after a trial built on these conflicting accounts, Gibbs was sent to Melbourne, where he was hanged on 12 November 1858 alongside another man condemned for a separate killing. The execution went horribly wrong: as the trapdoor dropped, the rope snapped under his weight and he crashed to the floor below, barely conscious. He was carried back up to the scaffold, fitted with a fresh rope, and hanged a second time, taking several more minutes to die.

Gibbs maintained his innocence to the last, screaming as the noose was fixed, "Mercy! mercy! I'm an innocent man; good people protect me, Oh God! Oh God!"

Ararat: Gold diggings scene 1854
Ararat: Gold diggings scene 1854

⬅ See all events from 12 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1929: She Asked for a Kiss, Then Bled to Death: Frederick Carr Hanged in Adelaide for Murdering His Wife

On the evening of 28 June 1929, Maude Carr walked into the police station near her home at Birkenhead, outside Adelaide, and asked if she could sleep in a cell. There was only one, kept clear for emergencies, so she was turned away. Hours later she was dead in the isolated weatherboard house she shared with her husband, Frederick Carr, her throat cut almost from ear to ear.

Carr's account was that he had woken to find his wife leaning over his shoulder asking for a kiss, then felt something wet. He ran to a neighbour's house drenched in blood, shouting that she had cut her own throat. A jury was not convinced: after five days of evidence they found him guilty of murder, though they added a recommendation for mercy.

Frederick Carr was hanged in Adelaide on this day in 1929, despite union campaigns pleading for his sentence to be commuted. He shook hands with gaol officials and walked calmly to the scaffold.

He denied the killing to the end, declaring from the condemned cell, "The law requires my body, but it cannot have my soul, as I am innocent."

Wooden house where Mrs Carr body found police and motor ambulance outside
Wooden house where Mrs Carr body found police and motor ambulance outside

⬅ See all events from 12 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1834: Acquitted by Half the Jury, Hanged by the Other Half: A Sydney Wife Murder

An inquest into the death of Sydney woman Maria McCormack ended in deadlock: seven jurors voted that her husband, Patrick McCormack, had not killed her, while five held firm for wilful murder. The numbers favoured him, and he walked free, the matter apparently closed.

The authorities refused to let it rest. McCormack was re-arrested and brought to trial, where a jury took barely half an hour to convict him of beating his wife to death. He was sentenced to hang, and the sentence was carried out in Sydney on this day in 1834.

McCormack made no confession on the scaffold, going to his death without admitting guilt or protesting his innocence.

Courtroom scene, Sydney c1817. Painting by Edward Charles Close (1790-1866)
Courtroom scene, Sydney c1817. Painting by Edward Charles Close (1790-1866)

⬅ See all events from 10 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

2001: Katherine Knight: the First Woman in Australia Sentenced to Life Without Parole for a Meat-Hook Murder

John Price's workmates watched him grow afraid of the woman he could not quite leave. In a town in the Hunter Valley region of New South Wales, Knight had already stabbed him once before, and on 28 February 2000 he took out a restraining order against her, warning colleagues that if he failed to turn up for work the next day, it would be because she had killed him.

He was right. Knight stabbed Price more than thirty times as he slept, then skinned him and hung the skin from a meat hook in the hallway. She cooked parts of his body with vegetables and set two places at the dinner table, each marked with the name of one of his children, as though preparing him to be eaten by them.

Knight first offered to plead guilty to manslaughter, then switched her plea to guilty mid-trial, prompting an overnight psychiatric assessment to confirm she understood what she was doing. On this day in 2001, she was sentenced to life imprisonment with no parole period at all, her file marked never to be released, the first time any woman in Australia had received such a sentence.

Knight never explained why she changed her plea, and even then she denied responsibility for what she had done, insisting she remembered nothing of the killing.

Aberdeen, New South Wales Australia
Aberdeen, New South Wales Australia

⬅ See all events from 8 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.