1882: He Ran From the O.K. Corral Gunfight, Then Started One He Could Not Survive

Billy Claiborne stood with Ike Clanton near Fly's Photography Studio when gunfire broke out at the O.K. Corral in Tombstone, Arizona, in October 1881. Unarmed and unwilling to fight, he bolted through the studio and escaped while Billy Clanton and the McLaury brothers were shot dead by the Earps and Doc Holliday. The humiliation never left him.

Claiborne blamed gunfighter Frank Leslie for killing his friend Johnny Ringo, and told a friend he was working double shifts in the mines just to save enough money to return to Tombstone and kill him. He got his chance on this day in 1882, drunk and abusive inside the Oriental Saloon, he was thrown out by Leslie, then waited outside with a rifle hidden behind a fruit stand. His shot went wide. Leslie's did not, and Claiborne died six hours later.

As he lay dying he reportedly said, "Frank Leslie killed Johnny Ringo, I saw him do it."

Billy Claiborne
Billy Claiborne

⬅ See all events from 14 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1953: Twin Brothers Who Became the After Dark Bandit, Unmasked by a Single Photograph

Peter and Doug Morgan, identical twins born in regional Victoria on this day in 1953, grew up to pull off more than twenty armed robberies across the state as the so-called After Dark Bandit, a single figure police hunted for two years without ever suspecting he was two men. Wearing matching clothes and disguises, the brothers struck rural banks and betting shops in towns just twenty minutes apart, sending detectives chasing a suspect who seemed able to be in two places at once. Their habit of striking near closing time and escaping into the bush under cover of darkness earned them their nickname.

The ruse unravelled on 27 April 1979, when Peter robbed the Heathcote bank for a third time and shot veteran constable Ray Koch twice, leaving him fighting for his life. Fleeing into the bush as nearly two hundred officers swarmed the area, he resurfaced the next morning walking through Bendigo with a suitcase, telling a suspicious unarmed constable, Rick Hasty, that he was headed to Melbourne to watch the football. Inside the case Hasty found a sawn-off shotgun, stolen cash and an old man's mask. When Morgan drew a pistol, he was unable to fire it, and as Hasty pinned him against a wall, he reportedly said, "You've got me, I just made you a hero."

The investigation took another extraordinary turn when detectives searching Peter's farm discovered a photograph of him sitting beside another man with the same face, moustache and sideburns. Detective Patrick Brear realised the truth and telephoned his partner: the elusive After Dark Bandit was not one man but two. Peter had an identical twin brother, Doug, and the pair had been using their matching appearances to outwit police for nearly two years.

After Dark Bandit(s)
After Dark Bandit(s)

⬅ See all events from 30 October

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1927: Laid Up with Influenza, Snowy Cutmore Was Shot Dead in His Sickbed by Squizzy Taylor

Snowy Cutmore had spent months hiding in Sydney after the gangland killing of an ally, but by late October 1927 he was back in Melbourne, lodging with his mother in Carlton. At the races he ran into his old rival Squizzy Taylor and the two traded threats in public; within days Cutmore came down with influenza and took to his sickbed.

On 27 October 1927, Taylor and an accomplice hired a car, drove to the house and walked straight into Cutmore's bedroom. Gunfire erupted between the bedridden man and his visitors: Cutmore was hit five times, his mother was wounded by a stray bullet as she rushed in, and Taylor himself staggered out mortally wounded, dying in hospital within the hour.

Snowy Cutmore dual portrait image from 1920
Snowy Cutmore dual portrait image from 1920

⬅ See all events from 27 October

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1927: The Last Gamble of Squizzy Taylor: a Bedroom Shootout in Melbourne

Squizzy Taylor, Melbourne's most infamous gang leader, walked into a Carlton sickroom on 27 October 1927 to settle an old score with his bedridden rival, John "Snowy" Cutmore. Within minutes, gunfire tore through the small house and both men were mortally wounded.

Taylor was rushed to St Vincent's Hospital in nearby Fitzroy, where he died that evening, aged 39, without ever naming who had fired the fatal shot.

The inquest returned an open verdict. One enduring theory holds that it was not Cutmore but his mother, standing over her dying son, who pulled the trigger that finally brought down Melbourne's most feared gangster.

Squizzy Taylor
Squizzy Taylor

⬅ See all events from 27 October

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.