1863: The Lover Whose Pistol Misfired: David Gedge Hanged in Melbourne for a Murder Near Mansfield

David Gedge was a 19 year old groom at a bush shanty near Mansfield, and the lover of the wife of its keeper, Robert Scott, who lay dying of delirium tremens in his bed. Gedge tried to shoot him himself, but the pistol would not fire, so he turned to Julian Cross, a servant on the property, melted down a charge of shot into a crude bullet, and ordered him to finish the job. After the single shot rang out, Gedge forced Cross to his knees and swore him to secrecy, then told the search party that Scott had killed himself.

The story collapsed within a day, and Gedge was the first to turn on his accomplice, naming Cross as the shooter. He, the victim's wife and Cross were all convicted of murder and hanged together in Melbourne on this day in 1863.

On the scaffold, the victim's wife turned to Gedge and asked him to clear her. He said nothing, and the trapdoor fell a moment later.

Devil's River district, near Mansfield, where the 1863 murder of Robert Scott took place. Artwork by Edward William Jeffreys, c. 1841–1845. State Library VIC
Devil's River district, near Mansfield, where the 1863 murder of Robert Scott took place. Artwork by Edward William Jeffreys, c. 1841–1845. State Library VIC

⬅ See all events from 11 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1863: On the Scaffold, She Begged Her Lover to "Clear Her": the First Woman Hanged in Melbourne

Elizabeth Scott ran a bush shanty with her husband Robert Scott on the road between Mansfield and the Devil's River, nursing him through a bad bout of delirium tremens while carrying on with her young groom, David Gedge. One night that April she sent a household servant into the sickroom with a loaded pistol; he shot Robert Scott where he lay, and the household then tried to pass the death off as a man taking his own life with a pistol left carelessly on the bed.

The story unravelled fast. The servant and Gedge each turned on the other, and both swore Elizabeth Scott had ordered the killing and handed over the gun herself. Tried and convicted alongside the two men, she was hanged in Melbourne on 11 November 1863, the first woman executed in the colony of Victoria.

On the drop she turned to Gedge and asked if he would not then "clear her". He said nothing, and the bolt was drawn.

Devil's River district, near Mansfield, where the 1863 murder of Robert Scott took place. Artwork by Edward William Jeffreys, c. 1841–1845. State Library VIC
Devil's River district, near Mansfield, where the 1863 murder of Robert Scott took place. Artwork by Edward William Jeffreys, c. 1841–1845. State Library VIC

⬅ See all events from 11 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1869: He Faked His Own Death to Escape His First Wife, Then Murdered His Second at Beechworth

James Smith, born Peter Higgins, solved an unhappy marriage in colonial Sydney by faking his own death, having a letter sent to his wife's family claiming he had fallen down a mine shaft and drowned. She rebuilt her life believing herself a widow, remarried, and prospered, while Higgins resurfaced years later under a new name, tracked her down and asked her to take him back. She refused.

He returned to his second wife, Elizabeth, at a mail station near Beechworth, where their marriage was marked by constant drunken violence and her threats to expose his bigamy. That July, Elizabeth was found dead in their bedroom, her body covered in fresh wounds and broken ribs. Smith was tried and convicted of her murder, and hanged inside Beechworth Gaol on this day in 1869.

At his trial he insisted his wife's injuries had come from being trampled by a loose horse, an explanation the court found impossible to credit; he went to the gallows without ever admitting his guilt.

Found Drowned, 1867, by George Frederic Watts. James Smith faked his drowning before facing the scaffold for murder.
Found Drowned, 1867, by George Frederic Watts. James Smith faked his drowning before facing the scaffold for murder.

⬅ See all events from 11 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1880: Such Is Life: Ned Kelly Hanged in Melbourne for the Murder of Constable Lonigan

Ned Kelly led Australia's most notorious bushranging gang, becoming a wanted man after the killing of three police officers at Stringybark Creek in October 1878. Among the dead was Constable Thomas Lonigan, whose murder would ultimately send Kelly to the gallows.

Captured after the dramatic siege at Glenrowan in June 1880, Kelly was tried and convicted of Lonigan's murder. He was hanged at the Old Melbourne Gaol in Melbourne on 11 November 1880, bringing one of Australia's most infamous outlaw sagas to an end.

As he stood on the scaffold, Kelly is remembered for words that, whether spoken exactly or paraphrased, have echoed through Australian folklore ever since: "Such is life." The calm acceptance of fate captured in those three simple words has resonated with generations of Australians.

Ned Kelly on the gallows: Such is Life
Ned Kelly on the gallows: Such is Life

⬅ See all events from 11 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.