Thomas Reeves: The Highwayman Who Made His Own Religion

Thomas Reeves grows up in old England as a tinman's son, indulged by a loving father who imagines a good life ahead for the boy. But young Tom falls in with freethinkers who mock religion and morality, and he swallows their philosophy whole: not because it enlightens him, but because it gives him permission to do whatever he wants.

Bold, reckless, and hungry for extravagance, Reeves becomes one of the most striking figures in the annals of true crime from old England: a man who leads a gang of highway robbers while quietly constructing his own private theology to keep his conscience silent. His story is a collision between violence and philosophy that still disturbs.

Listen now and walk the dark fields of Shoreditch with Thomas Reeves.

Thomas Reeves: The Highwayman Who Made His Own Religion

Follow the podcast so you never miss an episode:

Apple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusicMore apps

FROM THE 1735 TEXT

He had so far satisfied himself by considering the necessity of dying, and coined a new religion of his own.

CASE FILE No. 22
NAMEThomas Reeves
AGEabout 28
WHEN1722
WHEREShoreditch, London
CHARGEHighway robbery and assault
FATEHanged at Tyburn, 1722
SOURCELives of the Most Remarkable Criminals, 1735
HANGED

Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.

The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode.

Footpad: a robber who worked on foot rather than on horseback. In old England the distinction mattered: a highwayman rode, a footpad lurked in alleys and fields, and both could hang for the same offence.

Tinman: not a figure from a fairy tale but a metalworker who made and mended household goods from tin. In old England it was a respectable urban trade, the kind of steady livelihood a father might hope his son would carry on.

Priestcraft: a loaded word in old England, meaning the supposed manipulation of ordinary people by clergymen using religion as a tool of control. To call something priestcraft was to dismiss it as fraud dressed in vestments.

Sceptical persons: today a sceptic is someone who questions claims and demands evidence. In old England, calling someone sceptical often carried a darker charge: it meant they rejected God entirely, which put them outside the moral order of society.

Stand: when a robber cried 'stand' it meant 'stop where you are.' In old England this single word carried the full menace of a loaded pistol; it was the highwayman's signature command.

Intermediate state: a theological idea that the soul might pass through a waiting place between death and final judgement, neither heaven nor hell. Reeves asked about this in the condemned cell; not out of fear, apparently, but curiosity.

Suffered: today to suffer is to endure pain. In old England, when someone 'suffered,' it often meant they were executed: a grim euphemism that made the gallows sound like an act of passive endurance rather than state violence.

About This Series

Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines.

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

John Thomson: From Privateer to Street Robber

John Thomson grows up wild in London, a boy drawn to the company of thieves and drinkers, never once cracking open a Bible or any good book. By the time a kind friend arranges an apprenticeship with a weaver, the pull of a rougher life already has its hooks deep in him.

He ships out to war, returns, marries an honest woman, and then signs on as a privateer, where he learns that violence pays and pays well. What happens when a man trained in blood and plunder comes back to the streets of old England is the dark heart of this true crime story.

Listen now to find out what becomes of John Thomson, and how the sea changed him beyond saving.

John Thomson: From Privateer to Street Robber

Follow the podcast so you never miss an episode:

Apple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusicMore apps

FROM THE 1735 TEXT

He had never heard of or read a Bible or other good book throughout all that space.

CASE FILE No. 21
NAMEJohn Thomson
AGEabout 33
WHEN1722
WHERELondon, Smithfield
CHARGERobbery and violent assault
FATEHanged at Tyburn, 4 May 1722
SOURCELives of the Most Remarkable Criminals, 1735
HANGED

Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.

The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode.

Listed: today you might list items for sale; in old England, to list yourself meant to enlist, to sign up for military or naval service. Thomson listed himself in the sea service the way a restless young man might walk into a recruiting office.

Man-of-war: not a metaphor but a literal warship, armed and crewed for battle. Thomson served on one during Queen Anne's wars, and the miseries aboard; disease, flogging, hard rations; were notorious in old England.

Prizes: in naval warfare, a prize was an enemy vessel captured at sea along with its cargo. Nineteen prizes in under a year was extraordinary plunder, and Thomson's captain was clearly an aggressive hunter.

Cruise: forget leisure travel; a cruise in old England meant a privateer or naval patrol, sailing in search of enemy ships to seize. It was licensed violence on the open water, and it paid handsomely.

Creditable method of life: a respectable, honest way of earning a living. In old England, creditable carried the weight of public reputation; a creditable man was one his neighbours could trust and vouch for.

Fact: today a fact is a truth; in old England, it often meant a deed or an act, especially a criminal one. Being apprehended soon after this fact means being caught shortly after committing the crime.

Subsistence: bare survival, the barest level of income to keep body and soul together. Thomson went back to sea not for adventure but because weaving could not feed two mouths; subsistence was all he sought.

About This Series

Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines.

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

William Colthouse: The Highwayman Who Hid in a Hollow Tree

William Colthouse grows up in Yorkshire with a solid education and strong religious principles, but his head is full of dangerous politics: he is a fierce believer in hereditary right, and in the early days of King George the First's reign, his loud mouth lands him inside Newgate Prison.

It is there, among thieves and schemers, that Colthouse learns a new trade; within the walls of old England's most notorious gaol, a man who entered for seditious words comes out ready for the highway.

His is a true crime story of politics, family ruin and the road: listen now and follow it to the end.

William Colthouse: The Highwayman Who Hid in a Hollow Tree

Follow the podcast so you never miss an episode:

Apple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusicMore apps

FROM THE 1735 TEXT

William narrowly escaped by creeping into a hollow tree

CASE FILE No. 19
NAMEWilliam Colthouse
AGEabout 34
WHEN1722
WHERELondon, Hounslow Heath, Oxford
CHARGEHighway robbery and involvement in a prison escape plot
FATEHanged at Tyburn, 8 February 1722
SOURCELives of the Most Remarkable Criminals, 1735
HANGED

Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.

The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode.

Seditious words: in old England, simply speaking against the king or the government could get you locked up. It did not take a plot or a weapon: the wrong sentence in the wrong alehouse was enough to see you dragged to Newgate.

Jacobite: a supporter of the exiled Stuart line, who believed the throne had been stolen. In old England, calling someone a Jacobite was not a compliment; it marked them as a threat to the ruling order and a potential traitor.

Journeyman: today we use it loosely to mean someone competent but unremarkable. In old England it meant a skilled tradesman who had completed his apprenticeship but did not yet own his own shop; he worked for daily wages, and the word comes from the French 'journee,' meaning a day.

Hounslow Heath: the stretch of open land west of London that was practically synonymous with highway robbery. Travellers crossing it knew the risks; highwaymen knew the rewards.

Lay under condemnation: to wait in prison after being sentenced to death. In old England, the condemned sometimes lingered for weeks, receiving visitors, writing letters, and facing the slow approach of the gallows.

Forcing the prison: an escape attempt that involved breaking out by violence. It was a serious additional offence in old England and could seal a prisoner's fate even if the original charge was in doubt.

Suffered: in old England's legal language, to 'suffer' meant to undergo execution. It carried a note of religious endurance, as if the gallows were a kind of passion the condemned was made to bear.

About This Series

Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines.

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

Nathaniel Hawes: The Highwayman Who Refused to Plead

Nathaniel Hawes is barely out of boyhood when he starts stealing from his master's cash box, a young apprentice upholsterer drawn into expensive company that drains every penny he has. In old England, where the line between reckless youth and hardened criminal is razor thin, Hawes crosses it early and never looks back.

He builds a reputation among thieves for sheer nerve: robbing coaches single-handedly, holding up travellers on the Oxford Road, daring anything for the thrill and the applause of his gang. His story is one of the most striking true crime tales to come out of old England: a boy who mistook recklessness for heroism and dared the law to break him.

Listen now and follow Nathaniel Hawes from prison escapes and midnight heists to a reckoning he cannot bluster his way out of.

Nathaniel Hawes: The Highwayman Who Refused to Plead

Follow the podcast so you never miss an episode:

Apple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusicMore apps

FROM THE 1735 TEXT

It was nothing for Hawes singly to rob a coach full of gentlemen, to stop two or three persons on the highway at a time.

CASE FILE No. 15
NAMENathaniel Hawes
AGEabout 20
WHEN1721
WHERELondon, Finchley Common, Oxford Road
CHARGEHighway robbery and theft
FATEPressed with 250 pounds then hanged, 22 September 1721
SOURCELives of the Most Remarkable Criminals, 1735
HANGED

Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.

The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode.

Grazier: a farmer who raises and fattens cattle or sheep for market. In old England a rich grazier could leave a comfortable estate; losing that inheritance, as Hawes claimed happened to him, meant falling from prosperity into nothing.

Put him out apprentice: to be 'put out' was to be placed by guardians or parish into a binding contract with a tradesman. The master fed and housed you, you worked for years without wages; running foul of this arrangement, as Hawes did, left a young man with no trade and no safety net.

New Prison: not just any gaol, but a specific lockup in Clerkenwell, London, used for holding suspects before trial. It was grimmer and less famous than Newgate but no less feared by those crammed inside its walls.

Runners of the prison: low-ranking servants or turnkeys who fetched supplies and carried messages for inmates; in old England, prisoners who could pay could send these runners out for food, drink and firewood, which is exactly the favour the shoplifting woman exploited.

Crow: today we would say crowbar. In old England the word 'crow' alone meant the same iron lever used to pry stones, boards or bars loose; the woman heated one red hot and used it to wrench masonry from the prison wall.

Mute: to 'remain mute' in old England meant refusing to enter a plea of guilty or not guilty. This was not mere silence: it was a legal crisis, because a trial could not proceed without a plea, and the court had a terrible remedy for it.

Sentence of the press: the punishment known as peine forte et dure. Heavy stones or iron weights were piled on the prisoner's chest until he either agreed to plead or was slowly crushed to death. Hawes endured 250 pounds for over seven minutes before he gave in.

Levity: today the word means light-heartedness, but in old England, used of a condemned prisoner, it carried a darker edge: a reckless, almost manic refusal to take one's own death seriously, treating the scaffold like a stage.

About This Series

Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines.

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.