Nathaniel Hawes: The Highwayman Who Refused to Plead

Nathaniel Hawes is barely out of boyhood when he starts stealing from his master's cash box, a young apprentice upholsterer drawn into expensive company that drains every penny he has. In old England, where the line between reckless youth and hardened criminal is razor thin, Hawes crosses it early and never looks back.

He builds a reputation among thieves for sheer nerve: robbing coaches single-handedly, holding up travellers on the Oxford Road, daring anything for the thrill and the applause of his gang. His story is one of the most striking true crime tales to come out of old England: a boy who mistook recklessness for heroism and dared the law to break him.

Listen now and follow Nathaniel Hawes from prison escapes and midnight heists to a reckoning he cannot bluster his way out of.

Nathaniel Hawes: The Highwayman Who Refused to Plead

Follow the podcast so you never miss an episode:

Apple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusicMore apps

FROM THE 1735 TEXT

It was nothing for Hawes singly to rob a coach full of gentlemen, to stop two or three persons on the highway at a time.

CASE FILE No. 15
NAMENathaniel Hawes
AGEabout 20
WHEN1721
WHERELondon, Finchley Common, Oxford Road
CHARGEHighway robbery and theft
FATEPressed with 250 pounds then hanged, 22 September 1721
SOURCELives of the Most Remarkable Criminals, 1735
HANGED

Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.

The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode.

Grazier: a farmer who raises and fattens cattle or sheep for market. In old England a rich grazier could leave a comfortable estate; losing that inheritance, as Hawes claimed happened to him, meant falling from prosperity into nothing.

Put him out apprentice: to be 'put out' was to be placed by guardians or parish into a binding contract with a tradesman. The master fed and housed you, you worked for years without wages; running foul of this arrangement, as Hawes did, left a young man with no trade and no safety net.

New Prison: not just any gaol, but a specific lockup in Clerkenwell, London, used for holding suspects before trial. It was grimmer and less famous than Newgate but no less feared by those crammed inside its walls.

Runners of the prison: low-ranking servants or turnkeys who fetched supplies and carried messages for inmates; in old England, prisoners who could pay could send these runners out for food, drink and firewood, which is exactly the favour the shoplifting woman exploited.

Crow: today we would say crowbar. In old England the word 'crow' alone meant the same iron lever used to pry stones, boards or bars loose; the woman heated one red hot and used it to wrench masonry from the prison wall.

Mute: to 'remain mute' in old England meant refusing to enter a plea of guilty or not guilty. This was not mere silence: it was a legal crisis, because a trial could not proceed without a plea, and the court had a terrible remedy for it.

Sentence of the press: the punishment known as peine forte et dure. Heavy stones or iron weights were piled on the prisoner's chest until he either agreed to plead or was slowly crushed to death. Hawes endured 250 pounds for over seven minutes before he gave in.

Levity: today the word means light-heartedness, but in old England, used of a condemned prisoner, it carried a darker edge: a reckless, almost manic refusal to take one's own death seriously, treating the scaffold like a stage.

About This Series

Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines.

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

John Wigley: The Lone Highwayman of Finchley Common

John Wigley is a plasterer by trade but a highwayman by nature, prowling the lonely roads around Finchley Common for years before a single night of company brings him down. He lives with an old woman who sells brandy on the common: the same woman whose former husband turned up dead in a barn near Hornsey under circumstances no one can quite explain.

In old England, the solitary robber was a rare breed; most thieves ran in gangs, bound by oaths and mutual threat. Wigley despises gangs, convinced that when a man's life is on the line, loyalty crumbles: yet the one time he breaks his own rule and rides out with two accomplices, everything falls apart.

Step onto the dark roads of old England and hear what happens when a lone wolf makes one fatal compromise.

John Wigley: The Lone Highwayman of Finchley Common

Follow the podcast so you never miss an episode:

Apple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusicMore apps

FROM THE 1735 TEXT

When life came to be touched, they hardly ever failed of betraying all they knew.

CASE FILE No. 10
NAMEJohn Wigley
AGEabout 40
WHEN1730s
WHEREFinchley Common, Islington, London
CHARGEHighway robbery
FATEHanged, same day as the malefactors last mentioned
SOURCELives of the Most Remarkable Criminals, 1735
HANGED

Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.

The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode.

Ill courses: a polite way of saying a criminal lifestyle. In old England, to fall into 'ill courses' meant sliding from honest work into theft, fraud or worse: a moral descent wrapped in gentle phrasing.

Confederacies in villainy: organized criminal partnerships, what we would simply call gangs today. In old England, the word 'confederacy' carried a whiff of treasonous conspiracy, making even a band of petty thieves sound like plotters against the state.

Malefactor: a person who commits a crime, from the Latin for 'one who does evil.' Courts and chroniclers in old England favoured this term; it carried a moral weight that 'criminal' somehow lacks.

Benighted: today it means ignorant or unenlightened, but in old England it meant literally overtaken by nightfall while travelling. Being benighted on a country road was genuinely dangerous: you might stumble into a ditch, a barn, or the path of someone like Wigley.

Rapine and plunder: rapine is the violent seizure of property, a step beyond mere theft. Paired with plunder, it describes a life of aggressive, predatory crime: taking by force whatever you could carry.

Sessions: the regular sittings of a criminal court, typically held at the Old Bailey in London. In old England, the 'ensuing sessions' meant the next scheduled court date: your window between arrest and trial could be agonizingly short.

Immediate hand of Providence: the belief that God actively intervened to prevent criminals from prospering. Wigley himself observed this pattern: no matter how much a thief stole, the money seemed to evaporate, as though a divine force ensured crime never paid.

About This Series

Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines.

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.