1854: "Crankie Gunn": Hanged in the Only Public Execution Geelong Ever Held, for a Sword-Cane Murder

John Gunn, known locally as Crankie Gunn for his foul and reckless temper, was drinking with a woman named Charlotte Newman at her Warrnambool home when Samuel Harris, known as Dirty Sam, walked in and a jealous quarrel erupted. Gunn stormed off, returned armed with a sword-cane, a pistol and a dirk, and smashed her windows. When Harris went outside to calm him down, Gunn stabbed him through the stomach. Harris managed only to gasp "I am a dead man" before he collapsed and died.

Convicted of wilful murder at Geelong that October, Gunn was shown no mercy despite the jury's recommendation on account of provocation. He was hanged on this day in 1854 alongside another condemned man, before a crowd of 2,000 in the only public execution ever held in Geelong, at the notorious Gallows Flat.

On the scaffold Gunn asked to address the crowd and declare himself an innocent man, but was persuaded against it and went to his death in silence.

Corio Bay, Geelong, 1850. Watercolour drawing. State Library Victoria, H6702
Corio Bay, Geelong, 1850. Watercolour drawing. State Library Victoria, H6702

⬅ See all events from 9 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1863: The Hangman Was His Old Mate From Tasmania: James Murphy Hanged at Geelong for Killing a Warrnambool Constable

James Murphy was awaiting trial for horse theft in the Warrnambool jail when Constable Daniel O'Boyle walked him across to the courthouse on 4 August 1863 to light the morning fires. As O'Boyle knelt at the grate, Murphy came up from behind and beat him down with a mason's hammer, then calmly shut the door on his dying victim and walked off as if nothing had happened.

He was run down two days later at a dairy station on the Hopkins River, where he told his captors he had not meant to kill the constable, insisting he had "only struck him once"; he blamed the attack on how "brutally treated" he said he had been in the watchhouse.

At trial his defence argued that, taken from the jail without a fresh warrant, Murphy had been held unlawfully and any killing committed while escaping could be no more than manslaughter; the jury rejected it and convicted him of murder. He was hanged at Geelong on this day in 1863, with the hangman specially sent from Melbourne turning out to be an old friend of Murphy's from their years together in Tasmania; recognising him, the executioner wept before composing himself and carrying out the sentence.

Murphy made no address on the scaffold and offered no formal confession, though at trial he had all but admitted killing O'Boyle, claiming only that it followed a struggle rather than a cold attack.

James Murphy: Public Record Office Victoria, Central Register of Male Prisoners, VPRS 515/P0000, Prisoner Nos. 34624–35049
James Murphy: Public Record Office Victoria, Central Register of Male Prisoners, VPRS 515/P0000, Prisoner Nos. 34624–35049

⬅ See all events from 6 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1865: A Desperate Shootout on a Lonely Road Unmasked "Yankee Tom" as a Wanted Killer

Thomas Menard, known on the road as "Yankee Tom", shot his mate James Sweeney dead in a hut near Warrnambool on 10 June 1865 after what witnesses later described as relentless taunting between the two men; some swore Sweeney had reached for a quarrying hammer the moment Menard raised a pick against him. Menard fled south and vanished.

Police lost his trail for weeks. He resurfaced near Wodonga under the alias James Barrett, arrested over an armed robbery, and when Sergeant Bambrick recognised him a gunfight broke out on the spot: pistols fired at close range until Bambrick wrenched his wrist down, burying the shot in the dirt, and clubbed him senseless with the butt of his own revolver.

Menard was committed for trial and convicted of Sweeney's murder. He was hanged at Geelong on this day in 1865, having told the court at his committal that he had nothing to say.

Shootout on a lonley road.
Shootout on a lonley road.

⬅ See all events from 28 October

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.