1840: He Helped His Fugitive Friend Escape, Then Was Hanged for His Murder in Adelaide

Joseph Stagg, an escaped convict from Van Diemen's Land, had spent weeks hiding and feeding his fellow escapee John Gofton in the bush outside Adelaide, helping him dodge the police hunting them both. Then Gofton turned up dead, shot through the head near the Para River, with every track at the scene leading back to Stagg.

The case against him was entirely circumstantial, built on footprints, a borrowed horse and a missing gun, and no one could offer a reason why he would kill the man he had sheltered for so long. Stagg denied the murder from his arrest onward, but a jury convicted him regardless.

He was hanged on this day in 1840, on a new gallows raised on the parklands outside the gaol. It was the first public execution staged there, and around 700 people turned out to watch him die.

Rumours swept the town that he had confessed, or that fresh evidence had cleared him; neither was true. Stagg maintained his innocence of the killing to the very last.

South Para River, c. 1876. State Library of South Australia, B 1946
South Para River, c. 1876. State Library of South Australia, B 1946

⬅ See all events from 18 November

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

Subscribe to Dark Stories True Crime On This Day

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.