1216: The Poison Toad Theory Behind the Death of King John of England

Legend has it that King John of England was not felled by illness but by a monk's revenge. Staying at Swineshead Abbey in Lincolnshire that October, John allegedly threatened to starve his own kingdom with crushing bread prices; a monk is said to have milked a toad for its venom, mixed it into a cup of ale, and drunk from it himself before serving the king, to prove the drink was safe. The monk reportedly died first in the abbey infirmary, and John followed him within hours.

The king, already infamous for the Magna Carta he was forced to sign and then tried to annul, died at Newark Castle on 19 October 1216 as a rebel army closed in on his crumbling kingdom. The poisoning story only surfaces in a chronicle written decades later for John's old enemies, the barons; most contemporary accounts agree he died of dysentery, the far less dramatic verdict most historians still accept today.

Tomb of King John of England in Worcester Cathedral
Tomb of King John of England in Worcester Cathedral

⬅ See all events from 19 October

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

Richard James: Highwayman of the Oxford Road

Richard James is barely twelve years old when the world discards him. His father, a nobleman's cook, vanishes from his life early, and the boy is packed off to sea: a disposable child in old England's long machine of poverty and neglect.

What follows is a restless orbit of misfortune: captured by Spaniards, taken in by a kind house-painter abroad, drawn home by longing for England, only to find that England has nothing left for him. He marries too young, loses his wife to another man, and drifts toward the only trade that pays without asking questions.

His story is one of the rawest pieces of true crime from old England's highways: listen now and ride the Oxford Road with Richard James.

Richard James: Highwayman of the Oxford Road

Follow the podcast so you never miss an episode:

Apple PodcastsSpotifyAmazon MusicMore apps

FROM THE 1735 TEXT

He looked upon it as a very happy relief from a very troublesome and uneasy life.

CASE FILE No. 13
NAMERichard James
AGEabout 30
WHENEarly 1730s
WHEREOxford Road, Hanwell Green, London
CHARGEHighway robbery
FATEHanged at Tyburn
SOURCELives of the Most Remarkable Criminals, 1735
HANGED

Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.

The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode.

Profligate: in old England this did not simply mean wasteful with money; it described a person morally abandoned, someone who had thrown off all restraint. To call a man profligate was to say his soul was ruined as thoroughly as his purse.

Disobliged: today we might say 'offended' or 'alienated.' In old England, to disoblige someone was to undo whatever goodwill they owed you: a quiet, devastating word for burning your last bridges.

Betake him: an old reflexive phrase meaning to commit oneself to a course of action. When James 'betook him to the sea,' it meant he had no other path; it carried the weight of surrender.

Viz.: short for the Latin 'videlicet,' meaning 'namely' or 'that is to say.' Writers in old England dropped it into sentences the way we might write 'i.e.' today: a crisp, clipped signal that the ugly truth was about to be named.

Waggoners: not casual travellers but the commercial drivers hauling goods by wagon along England's main roads. Robbing waggoners on the Oxford Road was both profitable and ruthless: these were working men carrying other people's freight.

Reprieve: a temporary suspension of a death sentence. In old England a reprieve was not a pardon; it was a pause, a breath between the verdict and the rope, sometimes granted by royal mercy and sometimes simply delayed until the next hanging day.

Place of execution: almost always Tyburn, the notorious gallows west of London where crowds gathered to watch the condemned die. In old England, your last words at the scaffold were a public performance; the crowd expected a speech, and they judged you by how well you gave it.

Ignominious: shameful, publicly disgraceful. James used the word himself at the scaffold, naming his own death as a thing of dishonour: not because he feared it, but because he understood the spectacle the law was making of him.

About This Series

Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines.

Spread the word on your favourite platform!

1306: The Murder That Ended the Premysl Dynasty

On 4 August 1306, Bohemian King Wenceslas III was stabbed to death in Olomouc, cutting short the reign of a young ruler who had held the crowns of Hungary, Bohemia, and Poland. He was just 16 years old. His death extinguished the male line of the Premysl dynasty, a royal house that had shaped Central Europe since the ninth century.

With no male heir, the dynasty that had produced kings across three kingdoms collapsed in a single moment of violence. The Luxembourg clan seized Bohemia; the Piasts took Poland. The age of Premyslid rule was over.

/
Wenceslas III

⬅ See all events from 4 August

Spread the word on your favourite platform!
On This Day in True Crime History
1834·Risking the Gallows to Avoid a Flogging: Two Hanged in Sydney for the Murder of Dr Wardell
1834·Acquitted by Half the Jury, Hanged by the Other Half: A Sydney Wife Murder
1883·Not Afraid: Mah Poo Hanged in Adelaide for the Murder of Tommy Ah Fook
1986·The Escape That Ended the Birnie Killing Spree in Perth
More Crime On This Day →

Subscribe to Dark Stories

True crime stories, dark history and tour news, straight to your inbox.