1898: A False Name Could Not Save Him: Alfred Archer Hanged in Melbourne for Murdering His Camp Mate
Alfred Archer and his mate William Matthews had camped together for weeks near the Victorian town of Strathmerton when Matthews vanished that September; his body turned up sewn into sacks in a creek, his skull fractured and his throat cut. Archer fled to Melbourne and gave a false name, but a landlady who had put him up days earlier recognised him on sight. Confronted, he flung off his coat and blurted out, "I am Fred Archer. I admit selling the horse and cart, but I deny the rest."
At trial, a pickaxe was found to match the fracture in Matthews's skull and a knife from the camp fitted the wounds to his throat. Archer was convicted and hanged in Melbourne on 21 November 1898.
Though he had pleaded not guilty throughout, Archer had secretly confessed to the murder before his trial even began, a fact kept hidden until after his death; he admitted waiting until Matthews fell asleep before striking him with the pickaxe for the few pounds he carried, then cutting his throat to be certain. On the scaffold he thanked his gaolers, saying he was "prepared to meet my God."
